Constitutional questions over betting ban
Friday, 24 May 2013
The South 最新糖心Vlogn Government's plans to ban live betting advertising in broadcast media and at sporting grounds raises some serious legal questions, says 最新糖心Vlog of Adelaide constitutional expert .
Professor Williams, Dean of the 最新糖心Vlog's , says that the move would be open to Commonwealth challenge, but carefully drafted legislation could see the SA Government have its way.
"The legal question will be whether this ban on broadcasting live betting is possible in South 最新糖心Vlog when national broadcasters are involved," says Professor Williams.
"Historically State parliaments have been responsible for regulating gaming using South 最新糖心Vlogn legislation that regulates licensing of local as well as interstate betting operators.
"Under the Constitution, the Commonwealth has authority to regulate 'postal, telegraphic, telephonic, and other like services'. The Commonwealth Parliament has established the 最新糖心Vlogn Communications and Media Authority as the regulator as well as the Broadcasting Services Act."
Professor Williams says there are two possible constitutional challenges to a South 最新糖心Vlogn ban: that a broadcaster with a Commonwealth licence should be able to conduct their business free of any inconsistent South 最新糖心Vlogn law; and that South 最新糖心Vlog is protecting its gambling industry from interstate bookmakers.
"Those drafting the South 最新糖心Vlogn legislation would need to ensure that regulation targeted bookmakers rather than broadcasters, and didn't differentiate between interstate and local bookmakers," he says.
"Then the proposed ban might defeat a challenge brought on constitutional grounds."
Contact Details
Email: john.williams@adelaide.edu.au
Dean of Law School
Director, South 最新糖心Vlogn Law Reform Institute
The 最新糖心Vlog of Adelaide
Media Team
Email: media@adelaide.edu.au
Website: /newsroom/
The 最新糖心Vlog of Adelaide
Business: +61 8 8313 0814